‘Felice County Fair’ Adds Benny G, Michael Marcagi and Willie Watson — and the 26-Track Map Comes Into Focus

The tribute album for a band as prolific as The Felice Brothers was always going to be a logistical problem before it was a musical one. Twenty years of songs, most of them about people who never made it into anybody else’s songs. Where do you even start?

The answer, it turns out, is slowly. Felice County Fair (A Celebration of The Felice Brothers) arrives October 16 on Free Flight Records and Sun Mountain Records, and its makers have been releasing it a few tracks at a time since mid-July. On Friday they added three more: Benny G doing “Poor Blind Birds,” Michael Marcagi doing “Take This Bread,” and Willie Watson doing “Saint Stephen’s End.”

That makes 10 songs out for a record that runs 26 — and with the released tracks now carrying their final sequence positions, the shape of the thing is becoming legible. It is not a greatest-hits exercise. It is a career map, and it starts in 2006.

Felice County Fair at a glance

• What: Felice County Fair (A Celebration of The Felice Brothers), a 26-track tribute compilation
• Out: October 16, 2026, on Free Flight Records / Sun Mountain Records
• Newest additions (Aug. 28): Benny G, Michael Marcagi, Willie Watson
• Released so far: 10 of 26 tracks; 16 slots still unnamed
• Conceived by: Brandy Schultz, wife of Lumineers frontman Wesley Schultz
• Also confirmed, not yet released: Old Crow Medicine Show (“Penn Station”), Brandon Flowers, Deer Tick
• Companion film: a documentary directed by Tiller Russell, premiering fall 2026

What the three new tracks actually are

Willie Watson’s “Saint Stephen’s End” is the one with the most history folded into it. Watson co-founded Old Crow Medicine Show and left the band in autumn 2011, citing the road, new fatherhood and the group’s direction. Old Crow Medicine Show is also on this record, with a version of “Penn Station.” The tribute puts Watson and the band he walked away from on the same tracklist for the first time in well over a decade — not on the same song, but under the same roof, which for a record named after a county fair feels about right.

Watson has spent the years since building one of the more particular catalogs in American folk: Folk Singer Vol. 1 (2014) and Folksinger Vol. 2 (2017) for Acony, both produced by David Rawlings, then a self-titled 2024 album of original songs produced by Kenneth Pattengale and Gabe Witcher. He also played the Kid in the Coen brothers’ The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, singing “When a Cowboy Trades His Spurs for Wings,” which went on to an Academy Award nomination for Best Original Song. He lives in Woodland Hills.

Michael Marcagi’s “Take This Bread” is the commercial outlier here, and deliberately so. The Cincinnati singer-songwriter signed to Warner Records in January 2024 and watched “Scared to Start” climb to No. 54 on the Hot 100 and No. 9 in the U.K. on the back of TikTok. Two EPs followed — American Romance (2024) and Midwest Kid (2025) — and his debut album Under the Streetlights landed in February. Handing him a song from the Felice Brothers’ 2008 self-titled record is the compilation reaching for a listener who has never heard of Palenville, New York.

Benny G’s “Poor Blind Birds” is the least familiar name of the three, and the biggest swing. The Long Island guitarist — he started on violin, switched at six, later trained under Tomo Fujita at Berklee — has an artist page at the Grand Ole Opry that describes him as a “country-soul wunderkind” and lists John Mayer, Leon Bridges, Chris Stapleton and Ray LaMontagne as touchstones. He spends 2026 opening for Ty Myers on the road. At 4:44 his cover is one of the longest tracks revealed so far, trimmed from the Felice Brothers’ own sprawling 5:47 original on Undress.

The tracklist so far, and what it tells you

Because each released cover carries its final position on the album, the 10 tracks out now can be laid against the band’s discography. Runtimes are from Apple Music’s album listing.

Read down the fourth column and the intent is obvious. The compilation is not clustered around Undress or From Dreams to Dust, the records most likely to have brought a given listener in. It reaches all the way back to Through These Reins and Gone, the self-released 2006 debut that has never made it onto streaming services, and pulls out “Song to Die To” — a 1:27 sketch buried at track 11 — for Dan Reeder to cover in 1:18. Somebody involved in the sequencing has heard everything.

Reeder is his own argument for that. Born in Lafayette, Louisiana, he studied at Santa Ana College and then art at Cal State Fullerton, where he met the German wife he followed to Nuremberg; he has lived there for decades, earning his living as a painter, building his own instruments, and recording at home on a rig he assembled himself. He has a recording career at all because he mailed a stack of those home recordings to John Prine, who signed him to Oh Boy Records. Putting the shortest, oddest song on the album in his hands is not an accident.

Sixteen slots, and who is left to fill them

Positions 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11 through 15, 17, 20, 21, 23, 25 and 26 remain unannounced. Three contributors have been named without a release: Old Crow Medicine Show, whose version of “Penn Station” has been named in coverage of the album; Brandon Flowers of The Killers; and Deer Tick. That accounts for 13 of the 26 artists. The other half of the record is still dark.

This is a Woodstock-scene story before it is an Americana story

The press materials credit the album to Brandy Schultz, who is married to Lumineers frontman Wesley Schultz and who called the band with the idea roughly two years ago. That reads like a fan project until you trace the wiring underneath it.

Simone Felice — a founding member of The Felice Brothers, its drummer and one of its writers, who left in 2009 to form The Duke & The King — went on to produce The Lumineers’ Cleopatra and III, and co-produced Brightside with David Baron. Which is to say the producer behind three Lumineers albums is a Felice brother. The tribute did not come out of nowhere; it came out of a room these people have been sitting in together for well over a decade.

The loop closes tighter still. David Baron, Simone’s co-producer on Brightside, runs Sun Mountain Studio in Boiceville — the studio the album’s co-label, Sun Mountain Records, takes its name from. And Baron spent more than two weeks in June producing a brand-new Felice Brothers album at White Feather Farm in Saugerties, for Sun Mountain as a Sony Music Nashville imprint. No title, no date yet.

“The fact that so many artists have contributed to this project simply out of a love for our music fills us with both bewilderment and gratitude,” Ian Felice said of the tribute.

The cover is a Felice painting

The album art — riders on horseback along a ridgeline, a skeleton playing fiddle, a woman in a pink dress dancing with a white rabbit under a black sky — is signed ian felice in the lower right corner.

Ian Felice holds a B.F.A. in painting from Pratt Institute and works out of a converted church in Hillsdale, New York. He returned seriously to the easel after his son was born in 2017 and again when touring stopped in 2020, and has since shown twice with Half Gallery in New York — If the Hoarfrost Could Speak in 2023 and To find me, follow the pigeons in 2024 — drawing coverage from Artnet along the way. He has painted Felice Brothers covers before: Favorite Waitress (2014), Country Ham (2016), Undress (2019).

So the record where two dozen other artists sing these songs back at the band still has a Felice hand on the front of it. That is a stranger and better idea than a photograph of the band.

The California entries

For a record made almost entirely in and around the Catskills, the West Coast presence is quietly substantial. Dawes — the Los Angeles band built around brothers Taylor and Griffin Goldsmith, and about as direct an heir to the Laurel Canyon songwriting tradition as the city currently has — take “Jazz on the Autobahn,” from 2021’s From Dreams to Dust, at track 18. Willie Watson started turning up in Venice rooms around 2012 and 2013 and has been based in the city since. And Dan Reeder’s formal art training happened in Orange County before Germany claimed him.

The Felice Brothers themselves began in 2006 in Palenville, in the Catskill Mountains, and spent their early years busking the 42nd Street and Union Square subway stations while living in Brooklyn. The distance between that and a 26-artist tribute produced under a Sony Music Nashville imprint is the actual subject of the documentary arriving this fall — directed by Tiller Russell and produced by Gabriela Hearst, the artist collective Love and Squalor Quarterly, and Sony Music Nashville.

Frequently asked questions

When is Felice County Fair released?

Felice County Fair (A Celebration of The Felice Brothers) is released on October 16, 2026 through Free Flight Records and Sun Mountain Records. Apple Music’s album listing shows the finished record contains 26 tracks.

Which new songs from Felice County Fair are out now?

Three covers were added on August 28, 2026: Benny G’s “Poor Blind Birds,” Michael Marcagi’s “Take This Bread” and Willie Watson’s “Saint Stephen’s End.” They join seven earlier reveals, bringing the total released to 10 of the album’s 26 tracks.

Who is on the Felice County Fair tracklist so far?

Ten covers have been released with confirmed track positions: Bright Eyes, Bebe Stockwell, The Lumineers, Nathaniel Rateliff, Michael Marcagi, Dan Reeder, Dawes, Benny G, Ocie Elliott and Willie Watson. Old Crow Medicine Show, Brandon Flowers and Deer Tick have been named as contributors but their tracks have not yet been released.

Who created the Felice County Fair tribute album?

The project was conceived by Brandy Schultz, who is married to Lumineers frontman Wesley Schultz. She approached the band with the idea roughly two years ago and assembled the contributors.

Who painted the Felice County Fair album cover?

The cover painting is signed “ian felice” in the lower right corner. Ian Felice, the band’s singer and guitarist, holds a B.F.A. in painting from Pratt Institute and has painted several Felice Brothers covers, including Favorite Waitress (2014), Country Ham (2016) and Undress (2019).

Is there a Felice Brothers documentary coming out?

Yes. A feature documentary directed by Tiller Russell and produced by fashion designer Gabriela Hearst, the collective Love and Squalor Quarterly and Sony Music Nashville is scheduled to premiere alongside the album in fall 2026.

Are The Felice Brothers making a new album?

Yes. The band recorded a new album over more than two weeks in June 2026 at White Feather Farm in Saugerties, New York, produced by David Baron for Sun Mountain Records, a Sony Music Nashville imprint. A title and release date have not been announced.

More new-music coverage from The LA Note

• V Torres Took the Producer’s Chair for “Woman” — and the South Bay Gets It First
• Floyds Row’s ‘The Carlisle Sessions’: Eight Years in the Vault, Five Centuries of Song
• ‘Terra Olympia’: George Voukanos Trades the Orchestra for Synthesizers at the Birthplace of the Olympic Games

Felice County Fair (A Celebration of The Felice Brothers) is out October 16, 2026 on Free Flight Records / Sun Mountain Records. Ten of its 26 tracks are streaming now.